The Penalty Spot and the Portfolio

If you’ve read my blogs for a while, you’ll know I’m football obsessed. For most of the year, that means Liverpool. But every couple of years, when international football takes center stage, my attention shifts to England. Like every England fan, I convince myself that this could finally be our year. And then, all too often, the fate of a nation rests on a series of walks from the halfway line to the penalty spot.

Over the years, those penalties have taught me something the investment world knows well:

Confidence is easy when the outcome is hypothetical.

From the comfort of our sofas, every penalty seems simple.
“Just put it in the corner.”
“Don’t overthink it.”
“Why did he try that?”
After all, these are world-class players who have practiced penalties thousands of times.

Then the camera follows the player on that lonely walk to the penalty spot.
The stadium falls silent.
Standing in front of them is a towering goalkeeper. Behind them are teammates, managers, and an entire nation. Watching them are hundreds of millions of people around the world.

Suddenly, it doesn’t seem quite so simple. The penalty hasn’t changed. The pressure has.

That’s what makes penalties such a perfect metaphor for investment risk. In both cases, the challenge isn’t the mechanics. It’s the emotion.

At Beacon, we spend a great deal of time helping advisors have better conversations about risk because risk is intangible. It’s easy to talk confidently about how you’ll react when everything is hypothetical. It’s much harder to know how you’ll feel when the stakes are real.

Behavioral finance has taught us that people rarely make purely logical decisions during stressful moments. Fear, regret, overconfidence, and loss aversion all show up precisely when they are least helpful.

That’s why great advisors prepare clients for future versions of themselves.
The version that wakes up to alarming headlines. The version that sees their account balance lower than it was six months ago. The version whose neighbor has just announced they’ve “moved everything to cash.”

Because that version may answer the risk tolerance question very differently than the person sitting comfortably in the advisor’s office.

Perhaps that’s the real lesson from the World Cup.

Success isn’t determined by what people believe they’ll do when everything is calm.
It’s determined by what they actually do when the pressure arrives.
The same is true in investing.

For My American Friends: A Football Translation Guide

• Football = Soccer
• Goalkeeper = Goaltender
• Penalty = Penalty Kick (or PK)
• Pitch = Field
• Nil = Zero
• Boots = Cleats
• Kit = Uniform
• Extra Time = Overtime
• Clean Sheet = Shutout
• Offside Rule = A rule requiring diagrams, slow-motion replay, and approximately three hours to explain, so we’ll save that for another blog.

Song of the Month

There was never going to be another choice.

This month’s song is “Three Lions (It’s Coming Home)” by Baddiel, Skinner & The Lightning Seeds. Every major tournament, England supporters collectively convince themselves that football really is coming home. Logic may disagree, but hope has never been England’s problem.

I also have to give a respectful nod to my Scottish heritage and “It Only Takes One Lion” by Belle and Sebastian. Family loyalty demands it, even if our predictions for the tournament may differ.

Beacon is continuing to invest in behavioral finance resources for advisors. Whether it’s a behavioral finance tool, a client-friendly resource, or simply talking through a difficult situation with your Beacon wholesaler, our goal is the same: to help advisors prepare clients before they find themselves standing on their own version of the penalty spot. Reach out to your wholesaler today.

 

FOR ADVISOR USE ONLY. NOT INTENDED FOR CONSUMER SOLICITATION PURPOSES.

Beacon Capital Management, Inc. is an investment adviser registered with the Securities and Exchange Commission. Additional information about Beacon Capital Management is also available on the SEC’s website at www.adviserinfo.sec.gov under CRD number 120641. Beacon Capital Management only transacts business in states where it is properly registered or excluded or exempted from registration requirements.

Information presented is for educational purposes only and does not intend to make an offer or solicitation for the sale or purchase of any specific securities, investments or investment strategies.
Sammons Financial® is the marketing name for Sammons® Financial Group, Inc.’s member companies, including Beacon Capital ManagementSM.

NJS0612626